We may earn commissions on qualifying purchases.
Buysmart Logo

Best Yellow Mustard 2024

April 8, 2024

Welcome to our article, "Best Yellow Mustard 2024: A Comprehensive Guide with Shopping Tips." Yellow mustard, a beloved condiment with a rich history, offers a versatile flavor profile that complements a wide range of dishes. As you embark on your journey to find the perfect yellow mustard, it's essential to consider various factors to ensure that your choice aligns with your taste preferences and culinary needs.

In this guide, we will delve into the world of yellow mustard, exploring different flavor intensities, uses, and popular options in the market. Whether you are a fan of classic yellow mustard for your hot dogs or seeking a milder or spicier alternative, we have got you covered. By the end of this article, you will be equipped with the knowledge and insights needed to make an informed decision when selecting the best yellow mustard for your pantry. Let's dive in and uncover the mustard magic that awaits!


French's Classic Yellow Mustard: Classic Mustard for Every Kitchen

Alt text

French's Classic Yellow Mustard - 105 fl oz jar -- $5.38(Amazon)

French's Classic Yellow Mustard Dispensing Pouch with Fitment -- $31.24(Walmart - obatti)

Classic Yellow Mustard, 105 oz - One 105 Ounce Bulk Container of Tangy a... -- $5.38(Amazon)

Why We Picked It

French's Classic Yellow Mustard is a staple condiment that brings a tangy and creamy flavor to a variety of dishes. Its reputation for quality, combined with its use of natural ingredients like stone ground, #1 Grade Mustard Seeds, makes it a top choice for those seeking a classic mustard taste without artificial additives. The large 105 oz container options cater to both professional kitchens and home use, ensuring you never run out of this essential condiment.

Who It's For

This product is ideal for restaurant or food-stall owners in need of a bulk supply of mustard, as well as families or individuals who enjoy cooking and want to stock up on a versatile condiment. It's perfect for anyone looking for a gluten-free, low-fat option without artificial flavors. However, those prioritizing organic or non-GMO products might need to look elsewhere.

PROSCONS
✅ Made with natural ingredients and no artificial flavors, colorants, or dyes❌ Not specified as organic or non-GMO, which might be a concern for some consumers
✅ Gluten-free and low-fat, catering to various dietary needs❌ Single flavor option, limiting variety for those seeking different mustard tastes
✅ Available in bulk sizes, perfect for professional use or stocking up at home❌ Large size containers may not be practical for individuals with limited storage space

Heinz Yellow Mustard: Best Classic American Mustard

Alt text

Heinz Yellow Mustard (8 oz bottle) -- $1.67(Amazon)

Heinz Yellow Mustard 200 Case Pack -- $16.99(WebstaurantStore.com)

Heinz Mild Yellow Mustard -- $2.9(My Supermarket Compare)

Why We Picked It

Heinz Yellow Mustard is selected for its reputation as a classic American condiment, delivering a smooth and balanced taste that's become a staple in many households. It's particularly popular for enhancing the flavors of dishes at cookouts and BBQs, and the brand's commitment to using 100% natural ingredients, including top-grade mustard seeds, ensures a quality product.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for those who appreciate a traditional and familiar flavor in their condiments. It's best suited for consumers looking for a zero-calorie option to add zest to their meals without adding extra calories. However, it may not be the best choice for individuals who are sensitive to preservatives and additives.

PROSCONS
✅ Made with 100% natural ingredients, including #1 grade mustard seeds❌ Contains preservatives and additives, which may not suit all dietary preferences
✅ Offers a thick and rich taste that's well-balanced❌ Some consumers may prefer organic or artisanal mustard varieties
✅ Contains 0 calories per serving, making it a diet-friendly option❌ Packaging size options are limited, which may not be convenient for all users

Organicville Stone Ground Organic Mustard: Best Organic and Gluten-Free Mustard

Alt text

Organicville Organic Stone Ground Mustard 12 oz. -- $4.79(TheBetterHealthStore.com)

Organicville Stone Ground Mustard - Case of 12/12 oz -- $61.49(Target)

Why We Picked It

Organicville Stone Ground Organic Mustard is selected for its commitment to organic farming and clean eating. It's a great choice for health-conscious consumers who prefer products without artificial additives or preservatives. Its organic certification ensures that it's made with ingredients that are free from synthetic pesticides and fertilizers, while being gluten-free and containing no added sugar makes it suitable for a wide range of dietary restrictions.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for those who follow an organic lifestyle, have gluten sensitivities, or are looking to reduce their sugar intake without sacrificing flavor in their condiments. It's also perfect for anyone who prefers to support sustainable farming practices with their purchasing decisions.

PROSCONS
✅ Certified organic and supports sustainable agriculture❌ Higher price point compared to conventional mustard brands
✅ Gluten-free, catering to those with celiac disease or gluten intolerance❌ May not be as widely available as non-organic options
✅ No added sugar, appealing to health-conscious consumers and those monitoring their sugar intake❌ Some consumers might prefer a sweeter taste that comes from added sugars

Annie's Organic Yellow Mustard: Best Organic Mustard Choice

Alt text

Annie's Organic Yellow Mustard, 9-Ounces (Pack of 6) -- $44.89(Amazon)

Annie's Homegrown Organic Yellow Mustard, 9 oz, 2 pk -- $19.89(Amazon)

Annie's Naturals Organic Mustard, Yellow, 9 Ounce (Pack of 12) -- $60.04(eBay - shop_gourmet)

Annie's Organic Yellow Mustard, Gluten Free, 9 oz. -- $10.71(Amazon)

(1 Pack) Annie's Organic Yellow Mustard, 9 Oz -- $22.54(Walmart - shopGourmet.com)

Annie's Naturals Organic Yellow Mustard - 9 fl oz2 -- $14.14(Amazon)

Why We Picked It

Annie's Organic Yellow Mustard is selected for its commitment to organic and natural ingredients, providing a healthier condiment option for those who prefer organic products. Its traditional creamy texture and tangy flavor come from high-quality ingredients, and it's certified by USDA and Oregon Tilth, ensuring its organic status.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for health-conscious consumers and those with dietary restrictions, as it is vegan, gluten-free, soy-free, and dairy-free. It's also perfect for organic food enthusiasts who want to add a classic mustard flavor to their dishes without any added sweeteners.

PROSCONS
✅ Certified organic by USDA and Oregon Tilth❌ Milder flavor compared to some non-organic yellow mustards
✅ Free from gluten, soy, dairy, and sweeteners❌ Higher price point due to organic ingredients
✅ Traditional creamy texture with tangy white vinegar and spices❌ Limited availability in some regions

Sir Kensington's Yellow Mustard: Best Gourmet Twist on Classic Mustard

Alt text

Sir Kensingtons Mustard, Yellow - 9 oz -- $4.07(Vitacost.com)

Sir Kensington S Yellow Mustard, 15 Gram Packet , 600 per Case -- $126.49(Walmart - BuyItByTheCase)

Sir Kensington's Mustard, Yellow - 600 x 15 g pouch (9.0 kg/19.8 lbs) -- $85.53(Food City Ship to Home)

Why We Picked It

Sir Kensington's Yellow Mustard is selected for its gourmet approach to a classic condiment. It elevates the traditional yellow mustard experience by using high-quality ingredients and offering a unique flavor twist that distinguishes it from the standard options available on the market.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for culinary enthusiasts and those who appreciate artisanal condiments with a distinct taste profile. It's also suitable for consumers who prioritize clean ingredients in their food choices. However, it may not be the best fit for those on a tight budget or individuals who prefer the taste of traditional yellow mustard.

PROSCONS
✅ Gourmet version of classic yellow mustard❌ Unique flavor may not appeal to all palates
✅ Made with clean, high-quality ingredients❌ Higher price point compared to standard mustard brands
✅ Offers a unique twist on traditional mustard flavor❌ May not be widely available as more common brands

Plochman's Original Mild Yellow Mustard: Best Mild Mustard for Everyday Use

Alt text

Plochmans Mustard, Yellow, Original Mild - 10.5 oz -- $1.94(Walmart)

Plochmans Original Zesty Mild Yellow Mustard, 15 Ounce Bottle -- 12 per ... -- $37.95(FoodServiceDirect.com)

Plochman's Mild Yellow Mustard 19 oz -- $69.99(City Market)

Why We Picked It

Plochman's Original Mild Yellow Mustard is a classic condiment choice for those who enjoy a gentler flavor profile in their mustard. Its mild taste makes it a versatile addition to a variety of dishes without overpowering other flavors, which is why it's a staple in many Midwestern households.

Who It's For

This mustard is best suited for individuals or families who prefer a milder condiment that complements rather than dominates their food. It's also a good option for those with sensitive palates or who are introducing mustard to young children. However, it might not be the go-to choice for those who crave a bold, spicy, or tangy mustard kick.

PROSCONS
✅ Mild flavor that's not too spicy or tangy❌ May be too mild for those who prefer a stronger mustard flavor
✅ Versatile for a variety of dishes❌ Lacks the punch of spicier mustard varieties
✅ A favorite in the Midwest for its classic taste❌ Some may find it too plain for more adventurous palates

Gulden's Spicy Brown Mustard: Bold Flavor Enhancer

Alt text

Gulden's Brown Mustard, Spicy, 500 Count -- $32.83(Food City Ship to Home)

Gulden's 1 Gallon Spicy Brown Mustard -- $13.49(WebstaurantStore.com)

Gulden's Spicy Brown Squeeze Bottle Mustard 12 oz (Pack of 12) -- $21.12(Amazon)

Why We Picked It

Gulden's Spicy Brown Mustard is selected for its unique blend of heat and spice, offering a robust flavor profile that stands out from traditional yellow mustards. Made with premium grade mustard seeds, this mustard is perfect for those looking to add an extra kick to their meals. Available in various sizes, including a convenient squeeze bottle, it's versatile for both cooking and as a condiment. Additionally, its keto-friendly ingredient list, with 0g net carbs and 0g added sugar per serving, makes it a great choice for health-conscious consumers.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for culinary enthusiasts looking to elevate their dishes with a spicy twist, as well as keto dieters seeking flavorful, low-carb options. It's not recommended for those with a low tolerance for spicy foods or who prefer the mild taste of classic yellow mustard.

PROSCONS
✅ Made with premium grade mustard seeds for a robust flavor❌ May be too spicy for some palates
✅ Versatile use in cooking and as a condiment❌ Not a substitute for traditional yellow mustard in recipes
✅ Keto-friendly with 0g net carbs and 0g added sugar per serving❌ Bulk options may be too large for casual use

365 Everyday Value Organic Yellow Mustard: Best Organic Mustard for Everyday Use

Alt text

365 Organic Yellow Mustard - 8 oz -- $2.51(Amazon)

365 Organic Yellow Mustard - 14 oz -- $4.91(Big Hawaiian Flowers)

365 Organic Yellow Mustard 8 Ounce - 2 Pack -- $12.95(eBay - verkj)

Why We Picked It

The 365 Everyday Value Organic Yellow Mustard is a great choice for those who are looking for an organic condiment option that is both high in quality and affordable. As a product of Whole Foods Market's brand, it ensures that consumers are getting a product that meets stringent quality standards without breaking the bank.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for health-conscious consumers and organic product enthusiasts who shop at Whole Foods or prefer to buy their groceries online. It's also perfect for anyone looking to add a classic, tangy flavor to their dishes while maintaining an organic diet.

PROSCONS
✅ Certified organic, ensuring no synthetic additives or pesticides❌ Limited availability, primarily sold at Whole Foods stores or online
✅ Affordable price point for organic condiment❌ Price may be higher compared to non-organic mustard options
✅ Meets Whole Foods Market's rigorous quality standards❌ Packaging size options are limited

Inglehoffer Original Yellow Mustard: Best Traditional Mustard Experience

Alt text

Inglehoffer Mustard, Stone Ground, Original - 10 oz -- $2.84(Walmart)

Inglehoffer Original Stone Ground Mustard by Anderson's Neck Oyster Comp... -- $3.99(Anderson's Neck Oyster Company)

Mustard 3 Flavor Variety Bundle: (1) Inglehoffer Original Stone Ground M... -- $19.99(Amazon)

Why We Picked It

Inglehoffer Original Yellow Mustard is selected for its commitment to traditional flavor and creamy texture, which makes it a reliable choice for mustard enthusiasts looking for quality condiments. Its reputation for quality is upheld by the use of stone ground mustard seeds, providing a classic taste that complements a variety of dishes.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for those who appreciate a classic mustard flavor without the need for exotic or spicy twists. It's perfect for everyday use, from sandwiches and hot dogs to dressings and marinades. However, it may not be the best fit for someone seeking a mustard with a unique or bold flavor profile.

PROSCONS
✅ Creamy texture and traditional taste❌ May lack unique flavor compared to other specialty mustards
✅ Versatile condiment for various dishes❌ Slightly higher price point than some generic brands
✅ Quality product from a reputable brand❌ Packaging size may not be sufficient for heavy users

Boar's Head Delicatessen Style Mustard: Best Gourmet Deli Mustard

Alt text

Boar's Head Delicatessen Style Mustard Single Serve Packets (Case of 250... -- $50.95(MSM)

Boar's Head Delicatessen Style Mustard, 8.5 Oz -- $42.99(eBay - ntkdirect)

Boar's Head Deli Style Mustard with White Wine 9.5 oz -- $15.68(Walmart - Yyhtop Group Inc)

Why We Picked It

Boar's Head Delicatessen Style Mustard is selected for its reputation for quality and the brand's commitment to complementing their premium deli meats and cheeses. The mustard is crafted with attention to flavor that enhances a variety of dishes, making it a gourmet addition to any meal.

Who It's For

This mustard is ideal for food enthusiasts who appreciate gourmet condiments and are looking to elevate their sandwiches, dressings, and marinades. It's also perfect for those who already enjoy Boar's Head meats and cheeses and want a mustard that is specifically designed to pair with these products.

PROSCONS
✅ Crafted to complement Boar's Head meats and cheeses❌ Pricier than many other supermarket mustard brands
✅ Available in convenient single serve packets for on-the-go use❌ May be harder to find in some regions or stores
✅ Includes a variety with white wine for an elevated taste experience❌ Bulk case purchase may be too much for an average household


Thanks for checking out the best yellow mustard of 2024! If you have any more questions or need further recommendations, feel free to reach out. Happy shopping!

Recommendation Questions

I'm Looking for the Most Flavorful Yellow Mustard for 2024

I Want a Gourmet Yellow Mustard Option for 2024

I Need the Ultimate Yellow Mustard Recommendation for 2024

More Similar Content