Trolling spoons have been a staple in the fishing world for decades, and with good reason. These versatile lures are designed to mimic the movements of baitfish, making them irresistible to a wide range of predatory fish species. As we approach 2024, the market for trolling spoons is set to evolve, with manufacturers introducing new materials, designs, and technologies to cater to the ever-growing demands of anglers.
In the world of trolling spoons, material selection plays a crucial role in determining the lure's performance and durability. While traditional options like plastic and lead have been popular choices, the trend is shifting towards more advanced materials such as tungsten, titanium, and even carbon fiber. These materials not only offer superior strength and corrosion resistance but also allow for more intricate designs and precise weight distribution, resulting in enhanced action and fish-attracting capabilities.
Weight is another critical factor that anglers must consider when selecting trolling spoons. Lighter spoons, typically ranging from 1/4 to 1 ounce, are ideal for targeting species near the surface or in shallow waters. Conversely, heavier spoons, ranging from 1.5 to 2 ounces, are better suited for deeper waters and larger predatory fish. The weight of the spoon also influences its action, with heavier spoons often producing a more pronounced wobble or roll, while lighter spoons may exhibit a subtler, more erratic movement.
Stinger Magnum Spoon: Best Choice for Trophy Fishing
Michigan Stinger Magnum Stinger Spoon -- $9.99(FishUSA)
Michigan Stinger Magnum Spoon Lightweight Trolling Spoon 4.75" -- $5(smalapes)
Why We Picked It
The Stinger Magnum Spoon stands out for its robust construction and large size, specifically designed to attract and catch big game fish. Its reflective finish and enticing action in the water make it a preferred choice among anglers looking to up their game. The attention to detail in its design ensures that it mimics the movement of real fish, making it irresistible to targets.
Who It's For
This lure is perfect for seasoned anglers targeting large species in deep or open waters. It's especially suited for those who are not deterred by the challenge of handling heavier tackle and are looking for a reliable tool to land trophy catches. However, it might not be the best fit for beginners or those primarily fishing for smaller species due to its size and the required gear setup.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Heavy-duty construction designed for big game fish | ❌ May not be suitable for catching smaller game fish |
| ✅ Reflective finish and lifelike action attract predators | ❌ Requires a heavier tackle setup, which might not be ideal for all anglers |
| ✅ Large size makes it ideal for targeting trophy fish | ❌ Could be considered overkill for casual or beginner fishermen |
Dreamweaver Super Slim Spoon: Best Versatile Fishing Spoon
Dreamweaver Super Slim Spoon -- $7.79(Sportsman's Warehouse)
Dreamweaver Super Slim Spoon UV Double Green Spotted Dolphin -- $7.46(Amazon)
Dreamweaver Super Slim Spoon - 3-5/8" - Brown Sugar -- $6.99(Frank's Great Outdoors)
Why We Picked It
The Dreamweaver Super Slim Spoon is a top choice for anglers due to its slim profile and erratic action, which effectively mimics the movement of wounded baitfish. Its versatility across various water conditions and depths, along with its light-reflecting micro hex pattern, make it a go-to lure for catching predatory fish.
Who It's For
This spoon is ideal for anglers targeting pelagic predators such as trout. It's best suited for those fishing in light to moderate water conditions, where its slim design can perform the erratic action that attracts fish. However, it might not be the best choice for those fishing in very turbulent waters or requiring deep trolling techniques.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Slim profile mimics wounded baitfish | ❌ May not perform as well in very turbulent waters |
| ✅ Versatile across different water conditions and depths | ❌ Potentially less effective for deep trolling |
| ✅ Reflective micro hex pattern attracts fish | ❌ Specific design may not appeal to all fishing styles |
Moonshine Lures Shiver Minnow: High-Performance Glow Lure for All Conditions
Moonshine Lures Shiver Minnow -- $8.49(Frank's Great Outdoors)
Holographic Moonshine Shiver Minnow -- $8.99(Amazon)
Moonshine Lures Fat Bottom Shiver Minnow -- $8.29(FishUSA)
Shiver Minnow #3 Tuna Tic 1oz -- $8.99(Amazon)
Moonshine Lures Metallic Shiver Minnow #1 (Choose Color) -- $7.59(Anglers International Resources)
Moonshine Shiver Minnow (Razorburn, 3) -- $8.99(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
The Moonshine Lures Shiver Minnow stands out for its unique action and high-quality UV finishes, making it an excellent choice for fishing in low light conditions or deep waters. Its ability to glow in the dark, combined with a variety of sizes and colors, ensures that it appeals to a wide range of target species such as Perch and Walleye. The lure's design is specifically crafted to entice strikes, making it a valuable addition to any angler's tackle box.
Who It's For
This lure is best suited for anglers looking to enhance their fishing experience in various conditions. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced fisher, the Moonshine Lures Shiver Minnow can be a game-changer, especially when targeting species like Perch and Walleye. It's also ideal for those who fish in deeper waters or prefer to fish during dawn, dusk, or under overcast conditions where its UV reflective properties and glowing ability can truly shine.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Unique action that entices strikes from target species | ❌ UV finish may wear off over time with heavy use |
| ✅ High-quality UV finishes ideal for low light and deep water fishing | ❌ Purple or Violet glowing paint requires longer exposure to light for full charge |
| ✅ Available in a variety of sizes and colors to suit different fishing needs | ❌ Price varies slightly based on size and color options |
Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon: Best Versatile Fishing Spoon
Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon -- $8.99(Lake Michigan Angler A)
Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon Killer Dolphin 3 3/4 in. -- $8.49(Amazon)
Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon UV Caddy Shack 3 3/4 in. -- $8.99(Amazon)
Michigan Stinger Spoons - Standard Size - CU317 - Nuclear Purple -- $8.99(Tall Tales Bait & Tackle)
Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon Chartreuse Alewife 3 3/4 in. -- $8.99(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
The Michigan Stinger Standard Spoon is a top choice for anglers due to its effective design and versatility in catching a range of fish species. Its realistic swimming action and variety of new color patterns, including UV options for better visibility in different water conditions, make it a go-to lure for many fishing enthusiasts.
Who It's For
This spoon is ideal for anglers targeting Walleye, Trout, and Salmon, especially those who appreciate a lure that can be used effectively in various fishing scenarios such as trolling, casting, or jigging. It's particularly suitable for those fishing in the spring or in waters where small baitfish are present.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Proven effectiveness for multiple species | ❌ Some anglers report less durable color patterns |
| ✅ New UV color options for enhanced visibility | ❌ Single spoon per pack may not be sufficient for some |
| ✅ Made in the U.S.A. with a fish-attracting flutter action | ❌ May require additional tuning for optimal action |
Silver Horde Gold Star Kingfisher Spoon: Top Choice for Trolling Anglers
Silver Horde Kingfisher Spoon - Available in 3 Sizes and multiple styles... -- $13.89(False Creek Fuels Marine Store)
Gold Star Kingfisher Trolling Spoon - Silver/Purple/Ladder | Size: 3-3/4... -- $10.99(Fleet Farm)
Why We Picked It
The Silver Horde Gold Star Kingfisher Spoon is selected for its exceptional ability to attract fish, thanks to its aggressive swimming action and vibrant, eye-catching colors. These features make it a go-to choice for anglers looking to increase their catch rate. Available in multiple sizes and styles, including a striking Silver/Purple/Ladder option, it offers versatility and effectiveness in various fishing conditions. The affordability of this lure, with prices ranging from $10.99 to $13.89, ensures that it's accessible to a wide range of fishing enthusiasts.
Who It's For
This spoon is ideal for both novice and experienced anglers targeting species attracted to flashy and vibrant lures. Its design caters to those who appreciate the art of trolling and are in search of a reliable spoon that can cover a wide area to lure in fish. However, it might not be the best fit for anglers who frequently target species with particularly sharp teeth, as the finish may suffer from wear and tear over time.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Aggressive swimming action attracts fish effectively | ❌ Paint and finish may chip against toothy fish |
| ✅ Bright, flashy colors visible from a distance | ❌ May require replacement or touch-up over time |
| ✅ Available in multiple sizes and styles for versatility | ❌ Specific sizes and colors might not suit all fishing conditions |
Luhr-Jensen Coyote Spoon: Best Versatile Trolling Spoon
Luhr Jensen Coyote Spoon -- $10.83(Amazon)
Coyote Spoon -- $12.44(Amazon)
Luhr Jensen Coyote Spoon UV -- $3(smalapes)
South Bend Sporting Goods Luhr Jensen South Bend Sporting Goods Lure Inc... -- $12.67(Amazon)
Luhr Jensen Coyote Spoon, 3 inch -- $7.39(Sportco)
Luhr Jensen South Bend Sporting Goods Lure Inch ' -- $9.99(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
The Luhr-Jensen Coyote Spoon is a top choice for anglers due to its heavy-duty construction and effectiveness in attracting salmon in both freshwater and saltwater environments. Its versatility and performance, especially when paired with dodgers or flashers, make it a popular option for trolling enthusiasts seeking to match the baitfish prevalent in their fishing areas.
Who It's For
This lure is ideal for seasoned anglers targeting salmon who require a reliable spoon that can mimic the swimming action of local baitfish. It's particularly well-suited for those fishing off the coasts of Oregon, Washington, and Western Canada, where it has proven its worth. However, it may not be the best choice for those who prefer trolling at slower speeds and require a spoon with more flutter.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Heavy-duty and versatile for various environments | ❌ May not flutter as much at slower trolling speeds |
| ✅ Highly reflective UV Bright finish for increased visibility | ❌ Specific sizes needed to match local baitfish |
| ✅ Excellent swimming action behind dodgers or flashers | ❌ May require additional tackle (dodger or flasher) for best performance |
Warrior Lures Custom Painted Spoon: Best Customizable Fishing Spoon
Warrior Custom Painted 5" Shallow Set 2 -- $50(Reno Bait Company)
Warrior XL Trolling Spoon -- $7.99(Anglers International Resources)
Why We Picked It
The Warrior Lures Custom Painted Spoon is selected for its exceptional ability to be tailored to the specific needs of anglers. The customization options allow for a precise match to the local baitfish, which can be crucial for successful fishing trips. The variety of color patterns and finishes are designed to enhance the angler's experience by increasing the chances of attracting the target fish species in different conditions.
Who It's For
This product is best suited for avid anglers who understand the importance of 'matching the hatch' and are willing to invest in high-quality, custom gear to improve their catch rates. It's also ideal for those who fish in diverse conditions and require a versatile lure that can be adapted to various environments.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Customization allows for targeted fishing strategies | ❌ Higher cost compared to standard, mass-produced spoons |
| ✅ Variety of color patterns to match different fishing conditions | ❌ May require a deeper understanding of local fish preferences |
| ✅ High-quality finishes for increased durability and effectiveness | ❌ Customization options can be overwhelming for novice anglers |
Northern King Lures NK28 Spoon: Best Classic Trolling Spoon
Drawer #28 Northern King NK 28 Spoon -- $4.95(eBay - fishingfanatic66)
Northern King NK 28 Trolling Spoon Glowing Homeland Security; 3 3/4 in. -- $8.49(Sportsman's Warehouse)
Why We Picked It
The Northern King Lures NK28 Spoon is a tried-and-true option for anglers targeting salmon and trout, particularly in the Great Lakes region. Its reputation for durability and effectiveness makes it a reliable choice for trolling. The NK28's design has stood the test of time, and it continues to be a go-to lure for many fishing enthusiasts.
Who It's For
This lure is ideal for seasoned anglers who appreciate the classic approach to fishing and are looking for a dependable spoon that has proven its worth in the Great Lakes. It's also suitable for those who prefer a lure that is known to withstand the rigors of frequent use and the harsh conditions of freshwater trolling.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Renowned for durability and effectiveness | ❌ Limited selection of sizes and colors |
| ✅ Specifically designed for salmon and trout | ❌ Higher price point for specialized variants |
| ✅ Glowing Homeland Security color option for low-light conditions | ❌ May not be as innovative as newer lure designs |
Pro-Troll ProChip Flasher with EChip: Best Innovative Flasher for Predatory Fish
Pro-Troll ProChip 11" Flasher, Mountain Dew Chrome -- $14.39(Fish-Field)
Pro-Troll ProChip 11" Flasher, Chrome/Green -- $14.39(Fish-Field)
ProChip 11 Fin Flasher with Echip (Blue Plaid with Green Stripe, 11-Inch) -- $19.44(Amazon)
Why We Picked It
The Pro-Troll ProChip Flasher with EChip is selected for its advanced technology that simulates the electrical nerve discharges of wounded baitfish, which is a proven method to attract predatory fish like Salmon and Halibut. Its unique design, including a patented diagonal agitator fin, enhances the flasher's movement through the water, making it an effective tool for anglers looking to increase their catch rate.
Who It's For
This flasher is ideal for experienced anglers who are familiar with rigging and looking to up their game in both freshwater and saltwater environments. It may be less suitable for novice anglers due to the complexity of proper rigging and setup.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ EChip technology mimics wounded baitfish to trigger strikes | ❌ May require a learning curve for proper rigging |
| ✅ Durable ABS plastic construction with high-quality swivels | ❌ Could complicate setups for beginners |
| ✅ Versatile trolling speeds and effective diagonal fin action | ❌ Slightly higher price point for specialized technology |
Blue Fox Pixee Spoon: Best Lure for Clear Water Fishing
Blue Fox Pixee Spoon Gold/Green; 1/4 oz. -- $4.49(Sportsman's Warehouse)
Blue Fox Pixiee Spoon, 7/8-Ounce, Nickel/Fluorescent Orange -- $10.28(Amazon)
Blue Fox Pixee Spoon, 1/2 oz -- $8.76(Walmart)
Blue Fox 1/2-Ounce Rattlin' Pixee Spoon, Blue UV -- $9.1(Amazon)
Blue Fox Pixee Spoon - New Sports & outdoors | Color: Blue -- $6(Mercari)
Why We Picked It
The Blue Fox Pixee Spoon is a highly effective fishing lure, especially designed for clear water conditions. Its hammered finish and bright colors create an irresistible flash that mimics the natural movement of prey, making it a go-to choice for anglers targeting trout, salmon, and steelhead.
Who It's For
This lure is best suited for anglers fishing in clear water environments where visibility is high and fish are attracted to shiny objects. It's particularly effective for those targeting species like trout, salmon, and steelhead, whether they're fishing in rivers, streams, or the Great Lakes region.
| PROS | CONS |
|---|---|
| ✅ Hammered finish increases light reflection and flash | ❌ Single hook design may reduce hook-up ratio compared to treble hooks |
| ✅ Bright colors and egg sac insert enhance attraction | ❌ May not perform as well in murky or stained water conditions |
| ✅ Heavy construction allows for long casts and deep retrieves | ❌ Higher price point for larger sizes |
Thanks for checking out the best trolling spoons of 2024! If you have any more questions or need further recommendations, feel free to reach out. Happy fishing!